| Date | H/A | W/L | Team | Score | Opponent | Score | |||
| 2023-12-07 | H | W | Paw Paw | 55 | Mount View Christian (WV) | 33 | 141 | ||
| 2023-12-08 | H | W | Paw Paw | 55 | Union | 47 | 165 | ||
| 2023-12-13 | H | W | Paw Paw | 66 | Salisbury Elk-Lick (PA) | 48 | 345 | ||
| 2023-12-15 | A | W | Paw Paw | 76 | Harman | 47 | 589 | ||
| 2023-12-19 | A | W | Paw Paw | 63 | Mount View Christian (WV) | 32 | 648 | ||
| 2023-12-21 | H | L | Paw Paw | 49 | East Hardy | 86 | 677 | ||
| 2023-12-26 | A | L | Paw Paw | 53 | Clear Spring (MD) | 55 | 717 | ||
| 2023-12-27 | A | L | Paw Paw | 41 | Mt. Ridge (MD) | 72 | 736 | ||
| 2023-12-28 | A | W | Paw Paw | 76 | Turkeyfoot (PA) | 75 | 753 | ||
| 2023-12-29 | A | L | Paw Paw | 49 | Salisbury Elk-Lick (PA) | 61 | 777 | ||
| 2024-01-05 | H | W | Paw Paw | 67 | Harman | 43 | 1014 | ||
| 2024-01-08 | A | W | Paw Paw | 57 | Calvary (MD) | 48 | 1141 | ||
| 2024-01-12 | A | L | Paw Paw | 47 | Union | 55 | 1 OT | 1142 | |
| 2024-01-22 | H | W | Paw Paw | 64 | Timber Ridge (VA) | 28 | 1145 | ||
| 2024-01-23 | H | W | Paw Paw | 67 | Hancock (MD) | 58 | 1144 | ||
| 2024-01-27 | H | W | Paw Paw | 48 | Shanksville Stonycr. (PA) | 46 | 1567 | ||
| 2024-01-31 | H | L | Paw Paw | 46 | Pendleton County | 81 | 1130 | ||
| 2024-02-02 | A | W | Paw Paw | 78 | Hancock (MD) | 67 | 1147 | ||
| 2024-02-10 | A | L | Paw Paw | 43 | Pendleton County | 71 | 1132 | ||
| 2024-02-12 | A | W | Paw Paw | 62 | Timber Ridge (VA) | 25 | 1148 | ||
| 2024-02-21 | A | L | Paw Paw | 52 | East Hardy | 75 | 1149 | ||
| 2024-02-22 | A | W | Paw Paw | 67 | Legacy Christian (VA) | 31 | 1150 | ||
| 2024-02-26 | A | L | Paw Paw | 60 | East Hardy | 97 | A R1 S1 Semifinal | 1732 |